October 2015

First Success for New Law

The five family homes belonging to English pensioners in Oria, Almeria, which were threatened with demolition, will not be demolished; The Public Prosecutor decided to waive the demolition order, mindful of the recent law regarding buildings owned by buyers who bought in good faith.
This change to the Public Ministry’s charges , and the application of undue extended delay to reduce the terms of imprisonment and fines demanded for the promotors and builders for contravening planning laws, has made an out of court settlement possible. This was ratified in Almeria’s Criminal Court 2.

Gerardo Vázquez, legal advisor to AUAN (the Almerian equivalent of SOHA.ES), and lawyer representing two of the accused, (an octogenarian British couple), stressed the importance of the decision, and hopes that it will be followed in similar cases awaiting judgement, so that step by step the problem could be resolved to the benefit of everyone.

In the same vein, Julián Cazorla, the lawyer for another of the accused, also stated that the solution found in this case has opened the door for future cases. He further said that above all, the result relieved his foreign clients, who in reality were the victims, from their anxiety.

So at last there is a recognition that owners, who bought their houses in good faith and then are threatened with having their homes demolished, are the victims of a heartless bureaucratic injustice.

It is also clear that we would still be waiting for a solution to this problem if it were not for the formation and unceasing hard work of the associations like SOHA.ES and AUAN. With the help of lawyers like Gerardo Vázquez, they lobbied and demonstrated to make the changes to Spanish law in both the Criminal Code and the Civil Code. The Oria settlement would surely never have been made without those changes to the law. Anyone who has hired a lawyer to solve these problems will realise that this progress has not come cheaply. Your 25€ annual fee per household is now looking like incredible value!

In essence the change to the law gives a Judge the right to insist (when ordering a demolition of a house which was bought in good faith) that compensation is paid to owners before the demolition.
The Priors, whose house was demolished 7 years ago, are still waiting for the compensation to which an EU court ruled that they were entitled. Under the present law it is hoped that owners who bought in good faith will never again suffer the Prior’s appalling injustice.

Photos at SOHA.ES.es

Alcaucin Plans Viewed

SOHA.ES made the plans available to the public at La Era Restaurant, Puente Don Manuel, on Thursday.
170 interested people made their way to view the plans, and get advice from the SOHA.ES Committee members who gave their time to help.

This event seems to have provided a good opportunity for Alcaucin residents to find out what is planned for their homes, and for SOHA.ES to explain their aims difficulties and successes.

At and after the event, 6 Households became members of SOHA.ES
Sincere thanks to the 6 new member households. We need your support, and we are sure you will be getting good value.
Sincere thanks, as well for the 45€ donated to the fighting fund by generous residents at the event.

Photos at SOHA.ES.es

Next on the SOHA.ES Agenda

SOHA.ES has been invited by Ciudadanos, (the political party with whom we stand in elections) to attend the meeting at Sevilla, where the Junta de Andalucia will discuss proposed changes to the LOUA. (The LOUA is the planning law for Andalucia)
AUAN, our Almerian equivalent group, have also been invited to attend, by PSOE (the political party with whom they stand in elections).
Phil Smalley, Mario Blanke and Fernando Montero will be attending on behalf of SOHA.ES, and Maura Hillan will be be among those attending for AUAN.
The change being debated covers the section of the law governing non urbanisable land parcelled up for construction.
The change will allow EXISTING constructions more than six years old to be declared Asimilado como Fuera de Ordenacion
The issue is rather complex, so the full explanation will be given in the next Monthly update, hopefully after the changes have been made.

Housing:
Found in BoT 130 signs of revival

‘As British property investors resume their love affair with Spain, it’s the Costa Blanca which is proving to be top choice, accounting for 27 per cent of Spanish mortgage enquiries received at Conti over the last three years. And Spain continues to be top of the list for British buyers in general, accounting for just under half (45 per cent) of enquiries received by the company in the second quarter of 2015…’. From The Economic Voice.

Insuring “illegal” Houses

This question has been raised by SOHA.ES members in an email to Maria, the Membership Secretary. This is an excerpt from the email;

“… on the subject of …. Building and Contents Insurance on a property that has, or is likely to have, it’s building licence revoked, and therefore be deemed illegal.
Has anyone determined whether an insurance company would pay up on the event of an insurable claim such as a fire? As far as we understand it, insurers tend not to ask the question as to the legality of a house on the proposal form, but we assume that it would probably be an issue in the event of a claim. Would…….. the membership have any experience of this specific situation, and if so, what was the outcome?”

If any members have had experience of such claims, would they be kind enough to relate them to us, so that in next month’s News Update we can give some helpful information on this important topic.
Email Michael Stevenson <[email protected]> with your answers and comments, please.

Recent Posts

SOHA.ES participates in the conference on “suelo no urbanizable” in Mijas

Remember; SOHA.ES 2019 AGM January 23rd, 19.30 hrs at the Camping restaurant

More links from Spanish media at the bottom of this page

The possession of the municipality of Cala de Mijas hosted on October 26 an informative day on “the reality of undeveloped land” and the problem of housing built on this type of territory, which affects nearly 400,000 families.

The sessions were moderated by the councilor of Urbanism and Deputy Mayor of the municipality of Mijas, Andrés Ruíz León, who indicated that for once it would be convenient for the administrations to admit their errors in terms of urban legislation. “We are at the right historical moment to establish solutions and not patches.”

After the presentation and opening of the conference by Juan Carlos Maldonado, Mayor of Mijas, who explained that the objective is to provide ideas and establish a dialogue between those affected and administrations and that affects local economies, as buyers of Homes want guarantees and trust administrations.

Mario Blancke, spokesman for SOHA.ES and mayor of Alcaucín, made a presentation entitled “David against Goliath”, in which he explained that their struggle “is a matter of justice” and called for the need to trust the institutions.

“When these injustices occur, it is when the distrust in the administrations can begin,” Blancke added. “That’s why we want to work together with the administration to solve this problem for buyers in good faith.”

“However, we have been disappointed with the response from the administrations, which affects 300,000 homes in Andalusia, a real social drama,” concluded the mayor of Alcaucín.

For his part, Phil Smalley, president of SOHA.ES contributed his personal experience as a purchaser in good faith affected by a declaration of nullity of a work license granted by the municipality of Alcaucín. A situation of defenselessness to which still today is being submitted by the administrations. “We do not ask for an amnesty, as some propose, because that would be admitting that we have committed a crime.”

The interventions of Professor Jesús Jordano, professor of administrative law at the University of Seville, continued; of D. Venancio Gutiérrez Colomina, general secretary of the City of Málaga and associate professor of administrative law at the University of Málaga; and of Mr. Jorge Díaz Cadórniga, notary spokesperson of the Notarial Association of Andalusia on urban issues, who spoke about the real estate, cadastral and urban regularization of irregular housing.

The interventions of the three speakers gave a glimpse of the legal labyrinth that currently exists in urban planning legislation and that the successive modifications are actually patches, through interpretations.

They demanded a new decentralized urban law, because not all municipalities are equal, and the need to know the reality of the territories before legislating, to, on the one hand, avoid speculation and, on the other, the depopulation of rural areas, but that maintains the environmental conditions.

Diario Sur link here.

Mijas Communicacion link here.

SOHA.ES participa en las jornadas sobre suelo no urbanizable en Mijas

La tenencia de alcaldía de la Cala de Mijas acogió el pasado 26 de octubre una jornada informativa sobre “la realidad del suelo no urbanizable” y el problema de las viviendas construidas sobre este tipo de territorio, que afecta a casi 400.000 familias.

Las jornadas estuvieron moderadas por el concejal de Urbanismo y teniente de alcalde del ayuntamiento de Mijas, Andrés Ruíz León, que indicó que por una vez sería conveniente que las administraciones admitieran sus errores en materia de legislación urbanística. “Estamos en el momento histórico adecuado para establecer soluciones y no parches”.

Tras la presentación e inauguración de las jornadas por parte de Juan Carlos Maldonado, alcalde de Mijas, que explicó que el objetivo es aportar ideas y establecer un dialogo entre los afectados y las administraciones y que afecta a las economías locales, ya que los compradores de viviendas quieren garantías y confiar en las administraciones.

Mario Blancke, portavoz de SOHA.ES y alcalde de Alcaucín, hizo una presentación titulada “David contra Goliat”, en la que explicó que su lucha “es una cuestión de justicia” y reclamó la necesidad de confiar en las instituciones.

“Cuando se dan estas injusticias, es cuando puede comenzar la desconfianza en las administraciones”, añadió Blancke. “Por eso queremos trabajar junto con la administración para resolver este problema para los compradores de buena fe”.

“Sin embargo, nos hemos sentido defraudados con la respuesta por parte de las administraciones, que afecta a 300.000 viviendas en Andalucía, un verdadero drama social”, concluyó el alcalde de Alcaucín.

Por su parte, Phil Smalley, presidente de SOHA.ES aportó su experiencia personal como comprador de buena fe afectado por una declaración de nulidad de una licencia de obra concedida por el ayuntamiento de Alcaucín. Una situación de indefensión a la que todavía hoy está siendo sometido por las administraciones. “Nosotros no pedimos una amnistía, como algunos proponen, porque eso sería admitir que hemos cometido un delito”.

Continuaron las intervenciones del profesor Jesús Jordano, catedrático de derecho administrativo de la Universidad de Sevilla; de D. Venancio Gutiérrez Colomina, secretario general del Ayuntamiento de Málaga y profesor asociado de derecho administrativo de la Universidad de Málaga; y de D. Jorge Díaz Cadórniga, notario portavoz del Colegio Notarial de Andalucía sobre asuntos urbanísticos, que habló de la regularización inmobiliaria, catastral y urbanística de viviendas irregulares.

Las intervenciones de los tres ponentes dejaron entrever el laberinto legal que existe actualmente en la legislación urbanística y que las sucesivas modificaciones son en realidad parches, a través de interpretaciones.

Reclamaron una nueva ley urbanística descentralizada, porque no todos los municipios son iguales, y la necesidad de conocer la realidad de los territorios antes de legislar, para, por un lado, evitar la especulación y, por otro, la despoblación de las zonas rurales, pero que mantenga los condicionantes medio ambientales.